music

As has been noted (but understandably wasn't noticed by someone who gave it to me for Christmas), this book is basically a reprint of Marsh's classic Springsteen biographies "Born to Run" and "Glory Days". For detailing the early and mid-phases of Bruce's career, you'll find no finer works. Marsh is an excellent, very readable writer who clearly loves music and his books' subject. Marsh clearly helped document and establish some of Springsteen's deserved reputation as a genuinely decent human being and arguably one of the greatest figures in rock and roll. But Bruce's career didn't end in 1986, which is where the vast marjority of this book stops. To me, "Tunnel of Love" is Springsteen's most interesting album and tour, but only a few pages are devoted to it. I'm not interested in the details of Bruce's failed first marriage, but it clearly played a major role in the artistic formation of what I consider to be his best album. I understand why Marsh doesn't write a third volume- he's too personally tied to Springsteen, being married to Barbara Carr of Bruce's management organization. There's a very touching story about how Springsteen performed at the funeral of Ms. Carr's daughter- clearly, Bruce means more to Marsh and his family than simply the subject of a rock and roll biography. However, I'd still love to read his thoughts on Springsteen's life and career since the heyday of "Born in the USA", highly subjective though they may be. There are some brief introductions and updates that bring us up to the release of The Rising, but nothing is written in any great detail. So to suggest that this is a comprehensive biography of Springsteen up until 2003 is simply inaccurate. If you already own other editions of "Born to Run" and "Glory Days", I see absolutely no reason to buy this edition for anything other than collectability. If, however, you've never read those books, then by all means pick up this edition. There's a great, if incomplete story to be told.

Two Hearts combines two previously released books 'Born to Run' and 'Glory Days', adds a few new introductions and one more closing chapter covering the last 16 years (all in about 28 pages). If the title said 1972-1986, then this truly would be a 'Definitive' biography. But it's cover is extremely misleading and I would caution ANYONE interested in anything from Tunnel of Love forward to look elsewhere. Marsh truly cheats the reader by ignoring or glossing over such subjects as 1)the breakup of Bruce's first marriage, even though it basically is the subject of 'Tunnel of Love'. 2) His infidelities and the impact that it had on his fan base 3) breaking up with the E Street Band 4) The less than satisfactory shows in 1992/1993 and 5) the dual release of Human Touch/Lucky Town. These subjects deserve to have been addressed, especially by someone who has the access that Marsh has had and to truly round out the story.

Marsh's book often goes way overboard in its praise of Bruce's music, while rarely if ever addressing some of the common complaints many have had with the repetitive nature and theme's found therein. It would have made a much better book if some balance had been brought to the subject.

Its still a worthwhile read, but it only tells half the story. Perhaps someday we can get the rest.

First off, the positives. 1) Dave Marsh is an excellent writer who clearly loves his subject -- Bruce Springsteen -- and is great at bringing the concerts to life; 2) Springsteen himself is a fascinating figure, almost too good to be true (except that he's not!); 3) Many of Bruce's songs are brilliant, and Marsh does an excellent job exploring the themes -- life, death, movement, stasis, hope, despair, love, loneliness/alienation, faith, emptiness -- that run like a river through them all; 4) Despite obviously loving Springsteen and his music, Marsh rarely if ever sinks into the hero worship and "hagiography" he has been incorrectly accused of.

Now, the negatives. The book claims to be "The Definitive Biography, 1972-2003," yet it barely covers anything after 1986. Hey, that's 18 years ago; has so little happened in Bruce's life and music since then? In addition, I found the book to be a little repetitive at times, particularly in the introductory sections. But the most important criticism I've got is that, with the exception of "The Rising," the book largely ignores Springsteen's post-"Born in the USA" career: "Tunnel of Love," "Lucky Town," "Human Touch," "The Ghost of Tom Joad." These are all basically glossed over in a rushed, short, final couple of chapters. As much as I hate to say it, this makes me suspect that the publication of "Two Hearts," and its release just in time for the Christmas shopping season 2003, was in large part an excuse (by Dave Marsh?) to make a few bucks and to cash in on the post-"Rising" surge of interest in Springsteen. OK, sure, this IS America and it IS a MARKET economy, but I thought the whole book was about how Springsteen -- and by extension, Dave Marsh, his #1 fan and biographer -- only put something out there in the marketplace when it was ready from an ARTISTIC point of view. From that perspective, this book, which is really two previous books plus one quickie update covering 1987-2003, wasn't quite ready. Still, it's great for what it is, and Bruce Springsteen truly is an American hero worth emulating. At the least, it made me run to my stereo to listen to "Nebraska," "Live 1975-1985," and the rest with a heightened awareness of what it's all about. Bruce Springsteen truly is one of the greatest American artists ever; a national treasure to be listened to, appreciated, and savored, not the least in these difficult, dangerous, and frightening times.